By 
What are your options when you owe more than the house is worth?
When your mortgage balance is higher than what the house will sell for, a normal sale doesn’t work: the price can’t pay off the loan. That leaves a handful of exits, and none of them are painless. This guide compares them side by side so you can pick the least-bad one. If a foreclosure has already started, see facing foreclosure for the timeline.
This is general information, not legal or tax advice.
The options
Short sale. You sell for less than you owe, and the lender agrees to accept the sale proceeds and release its lien. It requires lender approval.
Foreclosure. The lender takes the house through the sheriff’s sale. In Minnesota you usually have a redemption period afterward.
Subject-to. A buyer takes over the house and your payments while the loan stays in your name. No lender approval to transfer, but the due-on-sale risk is real.
Loan modification. Keep the house with new terms from your servicer.
Bring cash to closing. Sell normally and pay the shortfall yourself.
Deed in lieu of foreclosure. Give the house back to the lender, with its agreement.
Side by side
| Short sale | Foreclosure | Subject-to | Loan modification | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lender approval needed | Yes | No | Not for the transfer | Yes |
| Typical timeline | Months | A year or more to end of redemption | 2 to 4 weeks | 1 to 3 months |
| Credit impact | Significant, usually less than foreclosure | Severe | Depends on payments after transfer | Mild to moderate |
| Deficiency risk | Depends on approval terms | Depends on foreclosure type | Loan stays yours | None if you keep paying |
| You keep the house | No | No | No | Yes |
| Main risk | Lender says no or slow-walks | Losing everything | Due-on-sale clause; buyer default | Can’t afford new payment |
How a short sale works
- Hardship package. You send the lender a hardship letter, income and expense documents, bank statements and tax returns.
- Purchase agreement. A buyer signs, subject to lender approval.
- Lender review. The lender orders its own valuation, reviews the offer, and approves, counters or denies.
- Approval letter. Read it carefully. Does it waive the deficiency? What must you sign?
- Closing. The lender receives the net proceeds and releases its lien.
Short sales take time. If a sheriff’s sale is scheduled, ask the lender in writing whether it will postpone while reviewing, and don’t assume it will.
When a subject-to structure fits
If your balance is close to the value, your rate is low and you need out, a subject-to sale can be faster and less damaging than a short sale. The loan stays in your name, and the buyer makes the payments. The risk: the lender can call the loan due under the due-on-sale clause, and if payments stop, your credit takes the hit. We explain that in writing, record the documents and use third-party servicing so you can see every payment.
Deficiency in Minnesota
A deficiency is the gap between what you owed and what the lender recovered. Whether a lender can pursue it depends on the type of foreclosure and the terms of any short sale approval. In Minnesota, lenders that foreclose by advertisement generally can’t pursue a deficiency judgment on a typical home loan, while judicial foreclosures and short sales work differently. Ask an attorney about your specific loan, and get any waiver in writing.
Canceled debt and taxes
Forgiven mortgage debt can be taxable income in some cases, and exclusions have changed over the years. Ask a tax professional before you close a short sale.
How to choose
- Want to keep the house and can afford a modified payment? Loan modification.
- Low rate, need out fast, can accept the due-on-sale risk? Subject-to.
- Deeply underwater, lender cooperative, time available? Short sale.
- Nothing else works? Foreclosure, with the redemption period as your last window.
Ryan will lay out each one with your numbers and your dates, in writing.